Top 5 Ways to Slash Your TIBCO Costs (without sacrificing value)

Preface

Nearly all clients are seeking greater prosperity in 2024.

While client organizations are still focused on cost reductions to meet the challenges of their new economic and market realities, the pent-up demands of the business are increasingly calling for innovation, automation, and organizational performance improvement.

Digital Transformation has emerged as the #1 Way to Boost Performance and Savings concurrently. Client organizations that are digitally transforming are harvesting greater value by:

• Automating tasks (RPA) to streamline efficiencies
• Unlocking data insights (ML) for better organizational (AI) decision-making
• Empowering flexible (Cloud) solutions for more cost-effective scaling

This drives greater innovation, improved organizational performance, and significant cost savings ranging from 25-30% (depending on industry, scope of transformation, maturity of transformation, and the methodology and execution) while at the same time, lowering risk by diversifying the technology supply chain.

Introduction

TIBCO isn't just about integration anymore. Rather, it’s a platform that can further enable your digital transformation journey by:

• Uniting Data Silos: TIBCO helps client organizations connect disparate data sources across their enterprises, providing a holistic and data-driven view for better evidence-based decision-making.
• Automating Workflows: TIBCO helps client organizations automate repetitive tasks, streamlining manual processes and freeing up valuable resources, allowing client organizations to focus more on higher-level strategic initiatives.
• Empowering Cloud Flexibility: TIBCO helps client organizations more easily scale-up operations with cloud-based deployments, driving down costs and resulting in greater agility to respond to the needs of the business as things evolve.

So, What’s the Problem?

Well, TIBCO isn’t exactly free, and many client organizations are feeling the pinch when considering TIBCO costs. The challenge clients are asking us to help solve is ‘how to reduce costs and risks in a way that does not negatively impact performance or value’. Here are the Top 5 ways to get the most out of your TIBCO investment and keep those costs in check:

#5: Unleash Your Inner TIBCO Ninjas: Knowledge is power, especially when it comes to TIBCO. Invest in training and certifications for your developers and admins. A skilled in-house team can manage deployments, troubleshoot issues, and customize configurations, reducing reliance on expensive external consultants.

• Cost: Even an average external TIBCO consultant can cost your organization $600,000 per year.
• Training: On average, three properly trained and certified internal resources can help client organizations avoid 50% of their external consulting expense.
• ROI: At $15,000 each of training expense ($45,000 total for 3 resources), training can help client organizations avoid $300,000 of external expense.

• Assessing your specific TIBCO training needs
• Recommending the most cost-effective training options based on your team's existing skillset
• Helping you develop a plan to maximize the value of your staff training

By investing in your team's TIBCO knowledge, you're building a future-proof capability that can deliver significant cost savings and greater operational agility over the long term.

#4: Open Source Can Be Your Friend: Not every integration needs the full TIBCO treatment. For simpler tasks, consider open-source alternatives like Apache Camel and Mule ESB. They can handle basic data exchange efficiently, freeing up your precious TIBCO licenses for the more complex integration scenarios.

• Functionality: Open-source alternatives might not offer the same breadth of functionality as TIBCO. Carefully evaluate your specific needs and choose the open-source tool that best addresses those requirements.
• Customization: Open-source solutions often require more customization compared to TIBCO's pre-built features. This can require in-house development expertise.
• Support: While vibrant communities exist for these open-source projects, they might not offer the same level of dedicated support as TIBCO.

NET(net) Can Help: We can assess your TIBCO usage, identify areas where open-source alternatives might be suitable, and help you develop a cost-effective hybrid approach that leverages both TIBCO and open-source tools to meet your specific integration needs.

Pro Tip: Identify non-critical and/or peripheral components within your TIBCO environment that can be substituted with open-source alternatives. TIBCO will often grant additional discounts to be more competitive and avoid a defection to a competitive open-source alternative for these integrations. The level of your willingness to change and your ability to communicate in an unambiguous way is directly proportional to how well this strategy works, so be completely prepared to migrate to another solution if TIBCO doesn’t grant any additional concessions.

Open-source solutions can be a great way to reduce costs and gain greater control over your integration environment. However, they require careful planning and potentially more internal resources compared to using TIBCO.

#3: Optimize Your Infrastructure: TIBCO can be resource intensive. Work with your IT team to identify bottlenecks and optimize your server configurations. Virtualization can be a game-changer, consolidating resources and reducing hardware costs. Don't forget to explore cloud based TIBCO deployments – they can be much more cost-effective than on-premises solutions.

• High Hardware Costs: Maintaining dedicated servers for TIBCO infrastructure can be expensive, especially with hardware refresh cycles.
• Hidden IT Costs: IT staff spends valuable time on server maintenance, patching, and troubleshooting, taking away from strategic initiatives.
• Limited Scalability: On-premises environments can struggle to scale up or down quickly to meet changing business demands.
• Software Licensing Fees: Customers pay annual licensing fees for their on-premises TIBCO software.

• Reduced Hardware Costs: No more managing physical servers! The cloud provider handles all the infrastructure, freeing you from upfront hardware investment and ongoing maintenance costs.
• Lower IT Overhead: The cloud provider takes care of server maintenance, patching, and upgrades, allowing your IT team to focus on core business initiatives.
• Elastic Scalability: Cloud based TIBCO deployments can easily scale up or down based on your processing needs. This eliminates the need for over-provisioning hardware, leading to cost savings.
• Subscription-based Pricing: Cloud based TIBCO often uses a pay-as-you-go subscription model. Customers only pay for the resources they use, eliminating the upfront licensing fees associated with on-premises deployments.

• Reduced IT infrastructure costs: Savings on hardware, software licenses, and IT staff time dedicated to server maintenance.
• Increased agility: The ability to easily scale TIBCO resources to meet fluctuating business needs.
• Improved focus on core business: Your IT team can dedicate more time to strategic projects that directly impact the bottom line.

NET(net) Can Help: We can assess your current TIBCO deployment, analyze the cost benefits of cloud migration, and help you develop a smooth transition plan to ensure a successful move to the cloud while maximizing your TIBCO investment.

#2: Right-size Your Deployment: One size does not fit all, especially with TIBCO. Audit your current usage. Are you paying for features you never use? Can you consolidate licenses across departments with similar needs? Can you switch to a different licensing model to gain economies of scale? Can you switch from an enterprise to a conventional licensing metric to get costs back in line with consumption?

Top 3 Common Features that TIBCO Customers Don't Fully Utilize:

1. BusinessWorks Container Edition: This feature enables you to deploy and manage TIBCO BusinessWorks applications in a containerized environment, providing increased agility, scalability, and cost-effectiveness.
2. TIBCO Spotfire Advanced Analytics: This analytics tool offers advanced capabilities such as predictive modeling, machine learning, and data visualization, but many customers underutilize its full potential.
3. TIBCO Cloud Integration: TIBCO's cloud-based integration platform provides connectivity and data exchange between on-premises and cloud applications, but its adoption is often limited.

TIBCO offers a range of licensing models to suit different customer needs. Here are some common licensing models:

• Per-Processor License: This model charges a license fee for each processor or core used to run TIBCO software.
• Per-Server License: This model charges a license fee for each server or virtual machine on which TIBCO software is installed.
• Per-Deployment License: This model charges a license fee for each deployment of TIBCO software, regardless of the number of processors or servers used.
• Named-User License: This model charges a license fee for each named user who has access to TIBCO software.
• Concurrent-User License: This model charges a license fee for each concurrent user who accesses TIBCO software at any given time.
• Enterprise-Wide License: This model provides unlimited usage of TIBCO software across the entire enterprise, regardless of the number of processors, servers, deployments, or users.
  
  

The specific licensing model that best suits your organization will depend on factors such as the number of users, the number of servers, and the intended use of TIBCO software. It's always recommended to consult with a NET(net) subject matter expert to determine the most appropriate licensing model for your needs.

#1: Negotiation is Your Superpower: The best time to claim value is before you sign the deal, but even annual renewals offer you a golden opportunity to reset the relationship! Don't just accept the status quo. Research competitor fit and pricing, leverage your existing relationship with TIBCO to elevate the discussion, and explore alternative options and licensing models.

#TIBCO, with 20% of the market, faces strong competition from #Mulesoft (17.8%), #SAP (16.7%), #IBM (15.6%), #Oracle (13.3%), and #Microsoft (11.1%), among others, including, but not limited to #SAS, #SoftwareAG, #Informatica, and #OpenText making up another 5.6%.

• Strengths: User-friendly interface with drag-and-drop capabilities, pre-built connectors for various applications, strong API management features.
• Considerations: Can be expensive for complex projects, licensing costs can be comparable to TIBCO.

• Focus: Tight integration with other SAP products, making it an ideal choice for businesses heavily invested in the SAP ecosystem (ERP, CRM, etc.).
• Strengths: Pre-built connectors for SAP applications, robust functionality for complex enterprise scenarios, cloud-based deployment for scalability.

• Strengths: Comprehensive suite for various integration needs (API management, data integration, application integration), hybrid cloud support (integrates well with on-premises and cloud environments), tight integration with other IBM offerings.
• Considerations: Complex architecture might require more technical expertise to manage.

• Focus: Cloud based integration platform (iPaaS) offering from Oracle. Integrates well with other Oracle products, especially Oracle Cloud applications.
• Strengths: Robust functionality for complex enterprise integrations, cloud-based deployment for ease of management.

• Focus: Easy-to-use integration platform built for the Microsoft Azure cloud ecosystem. Ideal for connecting Azure services and automating workflows.
• Strengths: Cost-effective for simpler integrations, integrates seamlessly with other Azure services, user-friendly interface.
• Considerations: Limited customization options, reliant on the Azure cloud platform.

• Strengths: Cloud-native architecture for ease of use and rapid deployment, strong data integration capabilities, user-friendly interface.
• Considerations: Limited functionality compared to some competitors for complex integration needs.

• Apache Camel: A popular open-source integration framework that excels at connecting disparate systems and applications. It offers a wide range of connectors and supports various integration patterns, making it a strong alternative for basic to moderate integration needs often handled by TIBCO BusinessWorks.
• Apache ActiveMQ: A robust open-source message broker that facilitates asynchronous messaging between applications. It's a viable contender for TIBCO Enterprise Message Service (EMS) for simpler messaging requirements.

• MuleSoft (Community Edition): While MuleSoft offers a paid enterprise platform, their open-source Community Edition provides a lightweight and flexible integration framework. It's a good option for basic integrations and API development, like TIBCO BusinessWorks' capabilities.
• Apache Kafka: This high throughput distributed streaming platform excels at handling real-time data streams. It can be a powerful alternative to TIBCO EMS for scenarios requiring real-time data ingestion and processing, especially for big data applications.
• Apache Spark: An open-source framework for large-scale data processing. While not a direct TIBCO replacement, it can handle data processing tasks often performed by TIBCO Spotfire or TIBCO Enterprise Runtime for R, particularly for big data analytics.
• Spring Integration Suite: This open-source suite offers a collection of modules for integrating applications and data sources within the Spring ecosystem. It can be a good alternative for basic integrations, especially for those already invested in the Spring framework.
  
  

Customer Success Stories: Here are 3 actual scenarios of TIBCO customers using the strategies mentioned in the blog post to drive savings and benefits with no diminution of value:

• Company: A large retail chain with a complex TIBCO environment for managing inventory, logistics, and customer loyalty programs.
• Challenge: High reliance on external consultants for TIBCO maintenance and troubleshooting, leading to significant yearly expenses.
• Solution: Implemented a training program to develop internal TIBCO expertise within the IT team. This included certifications for developers and admins, empowering them to handle deployments, troubleshoot issues, and customize configurations.

• Reduced external consultant usage by 50%, leading to substantial cost savings (estimated at $1.5 - $3.0 Million annually depending on consultant rates and project complexity).
• Increased internal IT team agility and responsiveness to business needs.
• Improved knowledge transfer and reduced reliance on external expertise for long-term cost savings.

• Company: A mid-sized manufacturing company utilizing TIBCO for some data integration tasks, but also facing simpler needs for application communication.
• Challenge: The cost of additional TIBCO licenses for basic integrations was straining the budget.
• Solution: After assessing the integration landscape, opportunities to leverage open-source alternatives like Apache Camel were identified. These tools handled basic data exchange efficiently, freeing up TIBCO licenses for more complex enterprise integration scenarios.

• Achieved significant cost savings by avoiding additional TIBCO licenses (potential savings of $100,000 - $500,000 annually depending on license tiers and usage).
• Maintained efficient data exchange for simpler tasks without compromising functionality.
• Optimized TIBCO usage for core enterprise integration needs.

• Company: A healthcare provider using TIBCO for data integration across various hospital systems, but suspecting they were overpaying for unused features.
• Challenge: Uncertain about the optimal TIBCO license configuration and potential cost savings resulting from cloud migration.
• Solution: A thorough TIBCO usage audit was conducted. Unused and underutilized licenses and features were identified for license reduction, license optimization, and enterprise consolidation. In addition, a plan was formulated to migrate the TIBCO environment to the cloud.

• Negotiated a revised TIBCO licensing agreement, eliminating unnecessary licenses and features, consolidating site specific licenses into an enterprise agreement, and greatly reducing costs (annualized savings of 33%).
• Successfully migrated the TIBCO environment to the cloud, achieving additional cost savings on infrastructure, hardware maintenance, and human resources.
• Optimized TIBCO deployment for specific needs and leveraged the cloud for scalability and agility, resulting in another monetary benefit of elasticity, nearly eliminating all need for upfront capital.

Independent Corroboration

Here are 5 articles that validate the general points raised in this blog and offer further insights into TIBCO cost optimization:

1. Reducing Costs While Embracing Digital Transformation Harvard Business Review: https://hbr.org/2023/07/the-value-of-digital-transformation. This article by Harvard Business Review emphasizes a key point from the blog: digital transformation can deliver cost savings alongside improved performance. It highlights strategies like automating tasks, optimizing IT infrastructure, and leveraging cloud solutions, all of which are applicable to optimizing TIBCO deployments.
2. Why Cloud Migration Can Be a Cost-Effective Option Forbes: https://www.forbes.com/sites/forbestechcouncil/2023/03/08/the-hidden-costs-of-cloud-migration/. Cloud migration is a strategy mentioned in the blog post for optimizing TIBCO infrastructure. This Forbes article explores the cost benefits of cloud migration, including reduced hardware costs, improved scalability, and simplified maintenance. These benefits can translate to significant cost savings for TIBCO deployments moved to the cloud.
3. The Role of Open Source in Enterprise IT TechBeacon:
   https://techbeacon.com/app-dev-testing/why-open-source-matters-developers. This blog post highlights open-source alternatives as a strategy to reduce TIBCO licensing costs. This TechBeacon article explores the growing role of open-source software in enterprise IT. It discusses factors to consider when adopting open-source solutions, which aligns with the considerations mentioned in the blog post for leveraging open-source alternatives with TIBCO.
4. IT Cost Optimization: Strategies to Reduce IT Spending Gartner: https://www.gartner.com/en/information-technology/topics/cost-optimization. This Gartner research paper explores various IT cost optimization strategies. While not specific to TIBCO, it provides valuable insights applicable to TIBCO deployments. Strategies like right-sizing software licenses, optimizing cloud usage, and renegotiating contracts all have parallels to the cost-saving tactics mentioned in the blog post.
5. Building an In-House IT Skills Development Program InformationWeek: https://www.informationweek.com/it-leadership/how-to-build-an-effective-it-training-program. The blog post emphasizes the value of developing internal expertise to reduce reliance on external consultants. This InformationWeek article explores strategies for building a strong in-house IT skills development program. Equipping your IT team with TIBCO knowledge aligns with the blog's suggestion of empowering "TIBCO Ninjas" to optimize costs and improve internal agility.

These articles provide valuable insights and perspectives that support the general cost-saving strategies mentioned in the blog for cost and value optimizing TIBCO deployments. Remember, the core strategies of internal skills development, open-source exploration, cloud migration, license optimization, and negotiation offer client organizations a good plan for cost-effectively leveraging TIBCO.

Summary

By implementing the strategies outlined in this blog in conjunction with a thorough analysis of your TIBCO environment, business needs, use cases, user demographics, consumption patterns, infrastructure needs, service level requirements, response time demands, delivery mechanisms, etc., you can potentially achieve significant cost savings and optimize your TIBCO investment for maximum value.

The best integration platform for you depends on your specific requirements and budget. NET(net) can help you navigate this process. We can provide a detailed analysis and develop a customized approach based on your unique needs and situation and can help you negotiate the best possible deal.

Remember, when it comes to IT optimization, there are two sides of the coin. Not only must you consider how best to minimize cost and risk, but you must also consider how best to maximize the realization of value and benefit. All of these conditions are subject to your specific opportunities and bound by your specific constraints, and you must do these things concurrently. This creates positive organizational friction between finance and IT, or FinOps and DevOps, igniting the ongoing process for value harvesting.

In the case of TIBCO, you should regularly monitor your TIBCO environment, identify areas for improvement, and work collaboratively with us to optimize the cost and value of your TIBCO deployments. By following these tips and leveraging the power of negotiation with NET(net) on your side, you can keep your TIBCO costs in check and maximize the value it brings to your organization.

Call to Action

NET(net) can help you maximize your savings and value on TIBCO if you Act Now.

About the Author

Steven C. Zolman is a leading expert in technology investment optimization and the founder and owner of NET(net), Inc., the world's leading technology investment optimization firm. With over 30 years of industry experience, Mr. Zolman has helped client organizations of all sizes maximize the value of their technology investments by minimizing cost and risk and maximizing the realization of value and benefit.

About NET(net) 

Founded in 2002, NET(net) is the world’s leading IT Investment Optimization firm, helping clients find, get, and keep more economic and strategic value in their technology supply chains. Over the last 20 years, NET(net) has influenced trillions of investment, captured hundreds of billions of value, and has helped clients cost and value optimize all major areas of IT Spend, including XaaS, Cloud, Hardware, Software, Services, Healthcare, Outsourcing, Infrastructure, and Telecommunications, among others. NET(net) has the experience you want, demonstrates the expertise that you need, and delivers the performance you demand and deserve. Contact us at info@netnetweb.com, visit us online at www.netnetweb.com, or call us at +1 (616) 546-3100 to see if we can help you capture more value in your IT investments, agreements, deployments, and relationships.

NET(net)’s Website/Blogs/Articles and other content is subject to NET(net)’s legal terms, offered for general information purposes only, and does not constitute legal advice. While NET(net) may offer views and opinions regarding the subject matter, such views and opinions are those of the content authors, are not necessarily reflective of the views of the company and are not intended to malign or disparage any other company or other individual or group.